Transporting a kayak safely is just as important as paddling it. The wrong choice of tie-down straps can lead to damage, frustration, or even dangerous situations on the road. While ratchet straps are commonly used for securing heavy loads, experienced paddlers overwhelmingly prefer cam straps when hauling kayaks. The reasons are rooted in the unique needs of kayak transport, where protecting the hull and ensuring stability matter more than brute force.
One of the biggest drawbacks of ratchet straps is the risk of over-tightening. Ratchet mechanisms are designed to apply significant tension, which is ideal for securing lumber, machinery, or other rigid cargo. Kayaks, however, are not rigid—they are made of polyethylene, fiberglass, or composite materials that can warp or crack under excessive pressure. When a ratchet strap is cranked down too tightly, it can deform the hull, create flat spots, or even cause stress fractures. Cam straps, by contrast, use a simple spring-loaded buckle that allows the user to pull the strap snug by hand. This provides enough tension to hold the kayak securely without the risk of crushing it. The human limit of pulling force is far safer for delicate gear than the mechanical leverage of a ratchet.
Another issue with ratchet straps is the bulk and weight of the ratchet mechanism itself. The large metal ratchet assembly is heavy, awkward, and often positioned close to the kayak’s surface. During transport, these mechanisms can rub against the hull, scratch gelcoat, or dent softer plastic. Even when carefully placed, the sheer size of the ratchet makes it difficult to avoid contact with the kayak. Cam straps, on the other hand, feature a small, lightweight buckle that is easy to position away from the boat. Their compact design reduces the risk of accidental damage and makes them easier to handle when loading or unloading.
Ease of use is another factor that makes cam straps the clear winner. Ratchet straps require threading, cranking, and releasing through a complex mechanism, which can be cumbersome when working around a roof rack or trailer. Releasing a ratchet strap under tension can also be tricky, sometimes requiring forceful manipulation that risks sudden loosening. Cam straps are straightforward: thread the strap through the buckle, pull it tight, and you’re done. To release, simply press the cam lever and pull the strap free. This simplicity saves time and reduces frustration, especially in cold weather when dexterity is limited.
Durability and longevity also favor cam straps for kayak hauling. Ratchet mechanisms are prone to rust, jamming, and mechanical failure if exposed to saltwater or grit. Their moving parts require maintenance and can seize up over time. Cam buckles, with their minimal moving components, are far more resistant to corrosion and wear. A quality cam strap can last for years with little more than rinsing and drying, making them a reliable investment for paddlers who haul their boats frequently.
Finally, cam straps are more versatile and forgiving. Because they don’t rely on extreme tension, they can be used for a variety of outdoor gear without risk of damage. Whether securing a kayak, canoe, paddleboard, or camping equipment, cam straps provide a balance of strength and gentleness. Ratchet straps, by contrast, are specialized for heavy-duty hauling and often overkill for recreational gear.
In conclusion, while ratchet straps have their place in securing industrial loads, they are poorly suited for kayak transport. The risk of over-tightening, the bulk and weight of the ratchet mechanism, and the potential for hull damage make them a liability for paddlers. Cam straps, with their lightweight design, ease of use, and safer tensioning system, are the preferred choice for kayak hauling. They protect the integrity of the boat, simplify the loading process, and provide peace of mind on the road. For anyone serious about paddling, cam straps aren’t just a convenience—they’re an essential safeguard for your kayak investment.